7 Best Workers Compensation Insurance Companies for Small Businesses 2021

Workers compensation insurance helps pay for injured workers’ health care costs if they experience work-related injuries or illnesses. It also protects your company legally in the event of an workplace injury, which makes workers compensation insurance both a legal requirement in most states and a financially safe move for business owners. Looking for the right workers comp coverage? Here are our picks for the best workers compensation providers for small businesses.

Bullhorn
Workers compensation insurance and COVID-19

The federal government hasn't issued any nationwide legislation requiring workers compensation insurance companies to cover COVID-19 (at least, not yet). However, a handful of individual states do require workers compensation coverage for COVID-19. Learn more about what your state requires on the National Conference of State Legislatures' COVID-19 workers comp page. We also recommend reading OSHA’s guidelines on minimizing COVID-19 risks in the workplace.

Best workers compensation insurance providers

The Hartford: Best overall

Hartford
  • Starting price: Contact for quote
  • Check
    Network of over 1 million health care providers
  • Check
    Easy-to-customize bundles

Want to bundle your business insurance instead of juggling multiple insurance providers? The Hartford is a good pick. As a company focused on small businesses, the Hartford’s packages include general liability insurance, business income insurance, and workers compensation insurance, and each package is easy to assemble and customize. The Hartford also provides the following perks:

  • Network of over 1 million US health care providers
  • Network of 65,000+ pharmacies across the US
  • Pay-as-you-go payment options
Hiscox
  • Starting price: Contact for quote
  • Check
    120 years of experience
  • Check
    Customizable insurance bundles

Hiscox was the first insurance company in the United States to offer online workers compensation insurance specifically for small businesses.1 Hiscox’s main selling points for business owners include the following:

  • Small-business-only focus
  • Monthly payment options with no added fees
  • Customizable bundles with general liability and professional liability insurance

Find the right workers compensation insurance for your business

Suracy: Best customer service

Suracy
Suracy
  • Starting price: Contact for quote
  • Check
    Competitive rates
  • Check
    Innovative online features

If you value customer service, put Suracy (known as AmVenture until 2019) at the top of your list. The company has a nearly five-star rating on Consumer Affairs2—much higher than Hiscox, which averages just one star on the same site.3 While Suracy focuses on church insurance, it offers workers comp insurance for small businesses too. And no matter what type of business you own or organization you’re a part of, Suracy offers the following benefits for you and your injured workers:

  • Focus on small to medium-sized businesses
  • Customizable policy bundles
  • 24/7 online claims filing

Travelers: Most popular

Travelers
Travelers
  • Starting price: Contact for quote
  • Check
    US's largest workers comp insurance underwriter
  • Check
    In-house medical professionals

Travelers is the biggest underwriter of workers compensation in the United States.4 With more than 2,000 workers compensation claim professionals who can walk you through the entire claims process, Travelers also has a solid focus on customer experience and customized insurance solutions. Other Travelers advantages include the following:

  • 500-plus in-house nurses and medical professionals
  • Pay-as-you-go options and payroll integration

Zurich: Most established

Zurich
Zurich
  • Starting price: Contact for quote
  • Check
    100-plus years of experience
  • Check
    Construction, health care, and manufacturing emphasis

This Swiss-based international carrier has more than a century of insurance experience. Zurich business insurance includes access to risk-management services that help you keep your workers safe and your premiums low. Features include the following:

  • Global coverage
  • Risk Engineering team to evaluate and reduce workplace danger
  • Civil suit assistance

Honorable Mentions

If none of our five favorite workers compensation companies meet your business’s needs, one of these providers could offer the insurance coverage you’re looking for.

biBERK: Nationally available

biberk logo
biBERK
  • Starting price: Contact for quote
  • Check
    Scalable workers compensation plans
  • Check
    In-house insurance agents

Berkshire Hathaway, one of the best-known names in the insurance world, is biBERK’S parent company. However, biBERK focuses specifically on small businesses. The company doesn't rely on outside insurance agents to find you the right workers compensation benefits. Instead, biBERK is a direct insurance carrier, which usually means you can get a faster quote (potentially at a better rate). Along with being a direct insurer, biBERK also offers these key benefits:

  • Availability in all states where private insurers compete
  • Loss control, safety training, and fraud identification

Chubb: Best program benefits

Chubb
Chubb
  • Starting price: Contact for quote
  • Check
    Return-to-work programs
  • Check
    Coverage for workers who travel internationally

Chubb workers comp insurance includes two impressive programs to help your business and your employees. The return-to-work program helps injured employees get back on the job quickly and safely, while the pharmacy benefit management program helps keep drug costs low. Other Chubb benefits include the following:

  • Special investigations unit for fraud detection
  • Medical and pharmacy benefit management program
  • Return-to-work program for quick employee recovery

The Most Dangerous States to Work in for 2020

It’s not uncommon to hear people sometimes grumble about their boss, a busy workday, or how stressed they are, but how many of us can really complain about how physically dangerous it is to go to work? You might be surprised.

According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, more than 5,000 people suffer fatal work injuries every year.5 There were even more workplace injuries that weren’t fatal, but still serious enough to land someone in the hospital.

This means that in addition to all the other choices business owners need to make, they also need to decide how much workers compensation insurance coverage they need—all while creating a safe work environment. What’s more, the stress of working in a dangerous environment can have long-term negative effects on employees who might not want to commit life and limb to the job.

U.S. map showing the safest and most dangerous states to work in 2020

The most dangerous state to work: Is it yours?

It should be no surprise that some states are more dangerous than others. But if you’re thinking this applies only to highly populated states like California or New York, you might be surprised by what zhulitouzi.com considers the 10 most dangerous states to work.

Rank
State
# of fatal work accidents (2016)
# of fatal work accidents (2017)
% change 2016–2017
Score

1

North Dakota

28

38

35.70%

14.7

2

Alaska

35

33

-5.70%

28

3

Vermont

10

22

120.00%

34.1

4

South Dakota

31

30

-3.20%

45.9

5

Mississippi

71

90

26.80%

50.4

6

Wyoming

34

20

-41.20%

51.9

7

Montana

28

32

14.30%

52

8

District of Columbia

5

13

160.00%

56.5

9

West Virginia

47

51

8.50%

59

10

Louisiana

95

117

23.20%

60

The safest state to work: Do you work there?

We also discovered the 10 safest states to work. The big surprise for us was that Connecticut, nicknamed “The Insurance Capital of the World,” ironically ranks only seventh on our list of safest states to work. And at number one? The Granite State. Way to go, New Hampshire.

Rank
State
# of fatal work accidents (2016)
# of fatal work accidents (2017)
% change 2016–2017
Score

1

New Hampshire

22

11

-50.00%

98.9

2

New Jersey

101

69

-31.70%

97.2

3

Rhode Island

9

8

-11.10%

95.3

4

Nevada

54

32

-40.70%

92.4

5

Delaware

12

10

-16.70%

90.7

6

California

376

376

0.00%

89.9

7

Connecticut

28

35

25.00%

87.1

8

Hawaii

29

20

-31.00%

86.5

9

Washington

78

84

7.70%

85.6

10

Virginia

153

118

-22.90%

85.2

Methodology

Our data is from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics—and we pulled their most recent data. We looked at the number of fatal workplace injuries per 100,000 residents who are 18 and older with a lower value positively impacting the score. We also factored in the percent of change from 2016 to 2017 with a lower value positively impacting the score.

Each measurement was normalized on a scale from 0 to 1, with 1 indicating a positive score and 0 negatively impacting the final score.

What does this mean for your business?

Business owners face a lot of challenges when building a successful and thriving business. Creating a safe workplace is one of those considerations that just can’t be ignored. Fortunately, as a business owner, you can impact the safety of the workplace, even if you do business in one of the dangerous states on our list.

Workers compensation insurance FAQs

What is workers compensation insurance?

Workers compensation insurance (sometimes known as workers comp or workman’s insurance) is a type of business insurance that helps pay for health care for employees’ work-related injuries or illnesses. It also covers legal fees for your business if an injured worker sues your company for damages. Most states require small businesses to have workers comp insurance.

Does my small business need workers compensation insurance?

If you have one or more employees, then yes, your small business needs workers compensation insurance. In fact, most states require employers to have workers compensation insurance. Why? Around 2.8 million nonfatal injuries or illnesses occur in American workplaces each year.5 Workers compensation insurance helps offset both health care and legal costs when employees are injured on the job.

Workers compensation insurance can also help pay for employee benefits like training for new jobs if an injury renders them unable to resume work at your company. It can also cover long-term physical therapy and help with short-term or long-term disability.

How much does workers compensation insurance cost?

The amount you’ll pay in workers compensation insurance premiums varies depending on how many employees you have and what industry you work in. For instance, businesses in the construction industry can expect to pay more in workers compensation premiums than call centers or coffee shops.

Methodology

We looked at 30 of the biggest and most promising small-business insurance carriers and spent over 60 hours researching the details of their workers comp policies. The companies that made it to the top of our list had the best combination of coverage options, competitive rates, and full-service features.

The takeaway

The right workers compensation insurance policy will give you—and your employees—peace of mind, ensuring business operations go smoothly and you and your employees get help when you need it.

Looking for more than just workers compensation insurance? Look at our picks for the best general liability insurance companies. You may be able to save money by bundling both types of insurance into one comprehensive package.

Disclaimer

At zhulitouzi.com, our research is meant to offer general product and service recommendations. We don't guarantee that our suggestions will work best for each individual or business, so consider your unique needs when choosing products and services.

Christa Baxter
Written by
Christa Baxter
Christa is an editor and writer with seven years of experience in educational publishing and content marketing. When she’s not editing or Tweeting, you can find her hiking the Wasatch Mountains, knitting this year’s batch of Christmas gifts, or binge-watching Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries.
Recent Articles
Feature image of a woman smiling across a table at another woman
What Is Human Resource Software?
A human resource information system (HRIS) is a type of software that handles most day-to-day...
Business people with laptop at desk
Best Small Business Management Software 2021
We honed in on the breadth and day-to-day value of various business management software contenders...
Gusto HR Software Review 2021
For resource-strained small businesses, Gusto shines with its premium access to human resources professionals that...
Two men using a computer to work
9 Skills an IT Specialist Should Have
In the US, hiring an IT specialist is easier said than done. The World Economic...